Hilary Clinton's defeat is wreaking havoc in the sisterhood.
Celebrity feminists are especially distraught. "Girls" star Lena
Dunham developed hives and fled to Sedona for spiritual renewal. Katy Perry
took to Twitter to declare "THE REVOLUTION IS COMING." For feminist
icon Robin Morgan, the election is proof that "a diseased patriarchy is in
a battle to the death with women."
But less excitable analysts are drawing more sober conclusions:
Perhaps the women's movement is too elitist and out of touch with ordinary
citizens, especially working-class women. That seems right, but I would go one
step further. Today's feminism is not merely out of touch with everyday
Americans; it's out of touch with reality. To survive, it's going to have to
come back to planet Earth.
Today's women's
movement also needs to reckon with the fact that men struggle just as much as
women.
Feminism
is drowning in myth-information. Advocates never tire of telling us that women
are cheated out of nearly a quarter of their salary; that one in four college
women is sexually assaulted, or that women are facing an epidemic of online
abuse and violence.
Such
claims are hugely distorted, but they have been repeated so often that they
have taken on the aura of truth. Workplace discrimination, sexual assault and
online threats are genuine problems, but to solve them women need sober
analysis, not hype and spin. Exaggerated claims and crying wolf discredit good
causes and send scarce resources in the wrong direction.
Today's women's movement also needs to reckon with the fact
that men struggle just as much as women. Modern life is a complicated mix of burdens
and advantages for each sex. Too often, feminism focuses on gender inequities
among elites: CEOs, MIT astrophysicists, U.S. senators. It is true that there
are too few women in those positions, but we need to consider the entire
workforce for context. Most backbreaking, lethally dangerous jobs — roofer,
logger, roustabout and coal miner, to name a few — are done by men.
Women's activists are now planning a Women's March on
Washington on Jan. 21. The organizers want to remind the new administration that
women's rights are human rights and for the world to "HEAR OUR
VOICE," in all caps. If I may offer some unsolicited advice: If that voice
is calm and judicious rather than hyperbolic and harping, people just might
listen.
Yes ... Hear our voice. I think it has been heard out loud .. as jan 21 march is over.. we have had few stalwarts being a part in that Sofia Ashraf and Padma Lakshmi
ReplyDeleteYeah.. It's time we talked about feminism.. properly. A woman is like a tea bag..you never know how strong she is until she gets in hot water.One of the reasons I am a feminist is because I think the patriarchy has a negative effect on males. We should raise our voice...
ReplyDelete